sno: 
43
Undefined
Requestreg No: 
DOHED/R/2019/50005
Request Category: 
nil
Request: 
To Date: January 1, 2019[dot] The Public Information Officer (PIO), Department of Higher Education, Ministry of Human Resource and Development, The Government of India, New Delhi-110 001[dot] Subject: To collect information through the RTI Act 2005, India regarding the selection of Prof[dot] Rajendra Pundik Deore as the Visitor Nominee for the Department of Mathematics, Indian Institute of Technology, Guwahati[dot] Dear Sir/Madam, I would like to convey that the current Head, Department of Mathematics IIT Guwahati Prof[dot] N[dot] Selvaraju communicated through an email that Prof[dot] Rajendra Pundik Deore, Head, Department of Mathematics, University of Mumbai, Mumbai has been appointed as the Visitors Nominee for our department for a period of three years[dot] Right after Head communication, the ex-head of Department of Mathematics IIT Guwahati, Prof[dot] Swaroop Nandan Bora (and present Dean of Student Affairs, IIT Guwahati) has complimented[dot] I quote, I find the selection very surprising in the sense that this name did not figure in the list of five names recommended by DFAC last year[dot] Here, DFAC stands for Department Faculty Affair committee[dot] I am attaching a copy of their emails[dot] This essential question is about Prof[dot] Rajendra Pundik Deore academic credential that does not look fit for the visitor nominee of the department of mathematics on an IIT[dot] There is no competition between the ex-visitor nominee and the present one[dot] Publications of Prof[dot] Deore are in very low profile journals in terms of reputation and scientific impact factor[dot] Prof[dot] Deore no way known for his mathematical contribution even among the mathematical committee in India[dot] It looks surprised in either way[dot] Question 1[dot] I would like to ask that, whether Prof[dot] Rajendra Pundik Deore name has been in the list of names recommended by IIT Guwahati to MHRDas Visitor Nominee for the Department of Mathematics, IIT Guwahati[dot] Kindly furnish the complete list of names recommended by IIT Guwahati as the Visitor Nominee for the Department of Mathematics, IIT Guwahati[dot] Question 2[dot] Please provide a copy of the procedure laid down for the selection of Visitor Nominee for a Department of an Indian Institute of Technology (IIT)[dot] Question 3[dot] Whether MHRD reserves the right to recommend a name for the Visitor Nominee for a department of IIT Guwahati (in general, for a Department of an IIT) to the honorable President of India other than from the recommended list of names by IIT Guwahati[dot] Finally, I request the concern PIO to provide the correct information without mixing reply of one question to others within the time frame prescribed under the RTI Act, 2005[dot] Thanking you, Sincerely, Dr[dot] Rajesh K[dot] Srivastava[dot] Address for correspondence: Department of Mathematics, Indian Institute of Technology, Guwahati - 781039, Assam, India[dot] Cell: 08762728805, 09415290070, email: rksri76[at]gmail[dot]c
Request Recvd Date: 
01/01/2019
Request Reply: 
Reply attached
Appealreg No: 
DOHED/A/2019/60020
Appeal: 
Thank for RTI reply. Every selection process is based on a comparative study of the profile of all the shortlisted candidates. Please, provide the basis of selecting Professor Rajendra Pundik Deore as the visitor nominee while rejecting other candidates those recommended by IIT Guwahati. I request to kindly give a comparative matrix for these candidates, based on the number of research papers, their reputation in terms of impact factors, awards, and recognization. Thanking you, Sincerely yours, Rajesh Srivastava.
Appeal Recvd Date: 
05/02/2019
Appeal Reply: 
Reply attached