sno:
331
Undefined
Requestreg No:
DOHED/R/2015/61884
Request:
To, Central Public Information Officer, MHRD, New Delhi. Dated:-. June 11, 2015 Subject: - Application under RTI-2005 Act. Dear Sir, I request you to provide answers to the following queries under RTI-2005 Act. The application is to seek information regarding letter ( F.No. 28-5/2012-TS-I, Govt. of India, MHRD, Deptt. Of Higher Education, Technical section-I) dated 26th November 2013, issued by Mr Alok Mishra (Director IIITs) to Director of IIITDand M Kancheepuram with Subject :- Career Advancement scheme (CAS) clarification-reg. The above said letter was put before the honble HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS, in the case W.A.Nos.2187 and 2188 of 2013. In the said case the honble court said:- respondent in his clarification letter dated 26.11.2013 has clearly stated that there is no provision for automatic movement or up-gradation to higher grade merely on completion of certain years of service and it has to be done only on the recommendation of a duly constituted selection committee The above said letter was presented before the honble high court as further explanation to para 3(ii) of MHRD directive (No.3-2712009-TS.11 Government of India, Ministry of Human Resource, Development ,Department of Higher Education, Technical Section-I1, New Delhi, 3oth December, 2009). The directive dated 30.12.2009 was issued as a part of pay commission recommendations for CFTIs. Please provide the following information:- 1.Please provide the name of members of the committee who decided to issue the above said letter dated 26.11.2013. Also please provide a certified copy of minutes of said meeting. 2.In case, no committee was constituted for amendment of above mentioned directive dated 30.12.2009. Then, please quote the rule under which Mr Alok Mishra (holding post of director at MHRD) on his own issued the above said letter dated 26.11.2013, which amounted to amendment of a document issued as part of pay commission recommendation. Regards, Bhupendra Gupta PDPM IIIT DM Jabalpur
Request Recvd Date:
11/06/2015
Request Reply:
Reply attached.
Appealreg No:
DOHED/A/2015/60374
Appeal:
To, Date: June 24, 2015 Appellate Authority, PDPM IIITDM , Jabalpur. Sub.: Filing the first appeal/complaint against the CPIO under section 19 of the RTI act. 1.Details of Appellant a.Name:- Bhupendra Gupta b.Address:- PDPM IIITDM Jabalpur, Dumna Airport Road, Jabalpur 482005 2.Details of Public Information Officer: a.Name:- Mr. Praveer Saxena 3.Details of RTI application to Central Public Information Officer: a.Application Filed online on:- 11/6/2015 b.Application received by CPIO on:- 11/06/2015 c.Reply by CPIO dated 16/6/2015 4.Particulars of payment of filing fee: a.Paid electronically Rs.10/- . Dear Sir, I would like to file a complaint against information provided by CPIO of MHRD Mr Praveer Saxena to a RTI application dated 11.06.2015. Through my RTI application I sought information to only one query. The CPIO in his reply has stated that The requisite information sought by you is not available with the undersigned. Precise information is not provided, the reply is vague. The reply can be interpreted by me as :- 1.That, no Committee was constituted for the amendment of MHRD directive dated 30.12.2009. And, Mr Alok Mishra issued the letter dated 26th November 2013 on his own. 2.That, Mr Alok Mishra transgressed his power in issuance of letter dated 26th November 2013. 3.That, without any rule/assigned power, Mr Alok Mishra issued the letter dated 26th November 2013. And, thereby on his own amended MHRD directive dated 30.12.2009. I request you to please provide me the required information or confirm my above conclusion as the reply is completely vague. Under RTI act precise information has to be provided. Also, take appropriate action on the CPIO for providing vague information. Regards, Bhupendra Gupta
Appeal Recvd Date:
24/06/2015
Appeal Doc URL:
Appeal Reply:
Reply Attached.
