Dear Sir, Recently there was comprehensive examination in Metallurgical and Materials Engineering department of IIT Kharagpur, 31st March 2016.There were two section one in general section and other research section and both the section are of 50 marks and total pass mark is 60.\n I have got 30 and 25 in general and research section respectively.Despite getting very poor marks like 17.5, 19 in general section others have passed.\n I feel that my guide Prof. Tarun Kundu has deliberatly not given marks to fail me and others students guide help them a lot . Now I want to know the marks of all students who appeared in this examination so that I can forward it to dean and director.